Western Horse Watchers Association
Exposing the Hypocrisy, Lies and Incompetence of the Wild Horse Advocates
The Nevada Department of Transportation installed eight miles of four-strand, four-foot livestock fencing along U.S. 50 in the Dayton area to reduce collisions between vehicles and wild horses, according to a report posted yesterday by KOLO News of Reno, NV.
Many more horses have been lost to the advocates than motorists and they are still the greatest threat to the herd, fencing notwithstanding.
RELATED: Fence Installation Next Week on South Edge of Virginia Range.
Back to the Salt River with Paul Kiely.
This is what the advocates bring to the table. The Montana Solution.
Helicopter roundups in slow motion.
And you’re still giving them money.
RELATED: Foal-Free Friday, Watching the Herds Disappear.
There are no announcements at the alerts & notices page regarding the closure order and no information has been posted about the wild horse roundup.
The incident began last September, with the capture of one wild horse using low-stress techniques, according to a news release by the Park Service dated October 8.
Now he’s been adopted, as explained in this article by The Journal of Cortez, CO.
The park is known for its cliff dwellings and wildlife. The horses are described as trespass livestock.
RELATED: Mesa Verde Roundup in Progress.
The 150 horses allowed by plan require 1,800 AUMs per year.
The True AML, the number of wild horses the HMA could support if it was managed as specified in the original statute, can be found as outlined in this post.
Section 3.2.2 in the Draft EA for resource enforcement actions in Three Fingers and Jackies Butte identifies two grazing allotments that intersect the HMA. The Western Watersheds map shows the arrangement. Click on image to open in new tab.
The Allotment Master Report provides the active AUMs.
Table 5 in the EA indicates that 28% of Board Corrals is inside the HMA, along with 39.2% of Three Fingers.
The forage assigned to livestock inside the HMA is 1,172 + 3,913 = 5,058 AUMs per year, assuming the resource is evenly distributed across the two allotments.
That amount would support 5,058 ÷ 12 = 423 wild horses.
The True AML is 150 + 423 = 573.
The current population, thought to be around 280 adults according to Section 1.2 of the EA, is well within this range. There is no justification for a roundup or fertility control program, which the Proposed Action would implement.
The stocking rate at the new AML, based on the acreage of Section 1.2, would be 573 ÷ 62,508 × 1,000 = 9.2 wild horses per thousand acres.
Given that the horses currently receive 26% of the authorized forage, neglecting wildlife, the HMA is managed primarily for livestock.
The 423 horses displaced from the HMA by permitted grazing represent about 0.8% of the 55,000 animals in off-range holding.
RELATED: Status of Three Fingers and Jackies Butte Allotments.
She’s reached her quota. The herd is too important to leave its genetics to nature.
Will the advocates put her back on PZP for the rest of her life or at least until she’s sterile so another mare can have her turn?
From this viewpoint, horses lost to contaminated water, collisions with vehicles, damaged fences, or otherwise removed from the area, are a good thing, they take some pressure off the darting budget.
RELATED: Fourth Foal of Year Appears on Currituck Outer Banks.
Approximately 900 animals will graze on 1,000 acres until late August, according to yesterday’s news release.
That’s equivalent to 180 wild horses.
The grazing season is 4.5 months so the total forage demand is 810 AUMs.
The equivalent stocking rate is 180 wild horses per thousand acres, compared to an average rate of one wild horse per thousand acres across all HMAs, many of which are on the lee (dry) side of the Sierra.
The ranch is on the windward (wet) side.
The announcement did not indicate if the sheepherder pays the BLM for the privilege or the BLM pays the sheepherder for the service.
The cost of the forage is about $1,100 at current grazing fees but the market value may be closer to $20,000.
RELATED: Targeted Grazing Begins Next Week at Cronan Ranch.
The advocates named him Cyclone, according to a story by 13 News Now, in honor of the fence that killed his dad?
They are so clever!
Birth rates and breeding patterns are controlled by the advocates, not the horses.
RELATED: Currituck Herd Grows by One.
Might as well watch a video while we wait for the Park Service to report the latest census results for the Maryland side of Assateague Island.
The herd is still trying to recover from the darting program, which was shut off in 2016.
The advocates point to the island as a paragon of wild horse management.
RELATED: Assateague Name-That-Foal Contest Starts Next Week.
The number of animals on lands managed by the BLM was estimated to be 82,384 as of March 1, compared to 86,189 a year earlier, according to today’s blog post.
Still, that’s three times more horses and burros than allowed by plan.
Imagine receiving a six bedroom home and finding out you can only use one bedroom.
You’ve been using three but you must vacate two.
The remaining five, representing 83% of the available space, have been reserved for the most noble and deserving non-native species on America’s public lands.
Don’t worry, the advocates will help you reach the goal.
Would you buy range-fed beef it you knew it was produced on public lands at the expense of our wild horses?
How about wine produced in an area where they once flourished?
What would you say if someone was trying to bury the truth about those horses?
This article by Wine Enthusiast, a trade publication, is silent about their history and isn’t even curious how the area got its name, but does identify some brands to avoid.
Near Cloudcroft, NM, Lincoln National Forest, with AleshireTX.
Section 3.2.2 in the Draft EA for resource enforcement actions provides information on the grazing allotments that intersect the HMAs.
The Three Fingers HMA lies within the Wildhorse Basin pasture of the Board Corrals Allotment and the Riverside pasture of the Three Fingers Allotment.
The Western Watersheds map shows the arrangement.
The Allotment Master Report from RAS puts Board Corrals in the Maintain category and Three Fingers in the Improve category.
The Jackies Butte HMA lies within the Dry Creek Native pasture of the Jackies Butte Summer Allotment.
The Allotment Master Report puts Jackies Butte Summer in the Maintain category.
Two of the allotments are in the Maintain category along with 68% of the public acres.
The average forage density in the allotments is 72.4 AUMs per year per thousand acres, enough to support six wild horses per thousand acres, on top of the 2.4 wild horses per thousand acres allowed by plan.
The government has stated repeatedly that public lands in the Western U.S. can only carry one wild horse per thousand acres (27,000 animals on 27 million acres), so that brings up the question “How many wild horses can these HMAs really support?”
Don’t look to the advocates for an answer.
RELATED: Draft EA for Three Fingers and Jackies Butte Out for Review.
A 15-page letter was sent to park officials, presumably by an attorney representing the group, according to a story posted this morning by INFORUM of Fargo, ND.
The article, which can be viewed by subscribers only, was posted to their blog.
A link to the complaint was not provided.
The herd now at TRNP was put there by the Park Service as an exhibit.
The original wild horses, thought to be descendants of Sitting Bull’s herd, were removed but some were rescued by Frank and Leo Kuntz. They called them Nokotas.
RELATED: Scoping Begins for Livestock Management Plan at TRNP.
Here are two listings that recently appeared on Zillow:
There is no Prop 13 in Nevada and assessed values can climb rapidly in seller’s markets.
On the bright side, as a land owner, you can tell the advocates that your property is off limits to their darting efforts.
Even if you don’t have property on the Virginia Range, you can still help the horses by not giving money to the advocates.
Listings for the area on Redfin, filtered for 10 acre lots minimum, can viewed here.
The behaviors described in this story by AP News are normal.
The question you should be asking is will their attempts to breed do any good?
The wild horse removal business is getting crowded.
The Campaign Against America’s Wild Horses is hiring, more volunteers are making the pilgrimage to Billings and every mare has a target on her.
The new pest control program for the Three Fingers and Jackies Butte HMAs, with its mandate for intensive fertility control, will be cheered by the advocates, who will not only embrace it but offer to apply it, assuring that most of the resources in the area go to the public-lands ranchers.
RELATED: Draft EA for Three Fingers and Jackies Butte Out for Review.
A BLM public affairs officer told Western Horse Watchers yesterday that a proposed grazing decision is subject to a 15-day protest period, which, for American Prairie, is now in progress.
A 30-day appeal period begins when/if a final grazing decision is issued.
All protest letters received must be reviewed to determine if they meet the standards of federal grazing regulations.
The PAO did not indicate if any such letters had been received.
The protest period for a proposed grazing decision is not an open comment period for the general public. Certified letters are sent to qualified parties, as defined by federal grazing regulations. The BLM can accept protest documents for consideration and any protest filed should document the reason(s) why the proposed decision is in error.
The PAO said the final grazing decision would be posted to the project website and would be accompanied by another news release.
RELATED: Any Challenges to American Prairie Grazing Decision?
The announcement appeared in the classifieds of the Argus Observer, not the BLM news site.
The project folder contains the EA only. No maps, notices or appendices were posted.
The Proposed Action, discussed in Section 2.2.1 of the EA, includes wild horse removals and intensive fertility control over a ten-year period. Treatment options include PZP, PZP-22 and GonaCon Equine.
The Three Fingers HMA covers 62,508 public acres in Malheur County, OR and the 150 horses allowed by plan require 1,800 AUMs per year. The target stocking rate is 2.4 wild horses per thousand acres.
The Jackies Butte HMA covers 65,211 public acres in Malheur County with the same AML and stocking rate. (Click on image to open in new tab.)
Both HMAs are subject to permitted grazing according to Section 3.2.2 of the EA.
Three Fingers lies within the Riverside pasture of the Three Fingers Allotment and the Wildhorse Basin pasture of the Board Corrals Allotment. Livestock inside the HMA receive about 5,000 AUMs per year based on data in Table 5.
Jackies Butte coincides with the Dry Creek Native pasture of the Jackies Butte Summer Allotment. Livestock inside the HMA receive around 4,000 AUMs per year using figures in Table 6.
The population management plan would enforce these forage allocations, ensuring that livestock are the primary consumers of resources in both HMAs.
Comments can be submitted by email until May 9.
On the Virginia Range with Victor champion. The advocates care far more about their standing with the bureaucrats and ranchers than they do about the horses.
RELATED: Foal-Free Friday, Dedicated to the Advocates.
Western Horse Watchers Association 