Western Horse Watchers Association
Exposing the Hypocrisy, Lies and Incompetence of the Wild Horse Advocates
On the range
Photo of VR stallion scouting out the territory on 05/04/18. A mare and foal lagged about 600 feet behind, awaiting instructions.
He decided things were not safe for the rest of the family so he circled back and moved them elsewhere.
Picked up by trailcam as he circled back. A contractor arrived on site while these photos were taken, pulling a trailer with backhoe, and that’s what spooked him.
Trailcam image of a coyote on the Virginia Range, 05/01/18. Temperature 29 °F, elevation 6500 feet.
On Kiger HMA.
The report has been on Drudge for two days. Did anybody test the water? Why couldn’t they move to other areas?
The Navajo Nation lies mostly in northeastern Arizona, extending into southern Utah and northwestern New Mexico.
Horses in this video, posted in 2015 by Nutnfancy, are almost certainly from the Onaqui Mountain HMA. The route taken by the riders, from Simpson Springs to Fish Springs NWR to Callao to Gold Hill, is described in this page at Wild Horse Tourist.
Simpson Springs was one of the mail stations along the historic Pony Express Trail.
This video tells the story of the Sheldon horses in NW Nevada, former inhabitants of Sheldon National Wildlife Refuge. Rounded up a few years ago. The area is managed by the FWS, not the BLM, although a BLM contractor was involved in the gathers.
The size of the refuge is 574,000 acres, and at the time of the removals there were 800 horses and 90 burros roaming the land, for a stocking rate of 1.6 animals per thousand acres, almost twice the rate of your average HMA in Nevada.
The gathers themselves, sometimes difficult to watch, are an effect, not a cause. Instead of criticizing the contractor, question the basis on which they were justified. Does everything appear to be legit?
For example, this section of the SNWR brochure indicates that plants grow back quickly after a fire but grow slowly after grazing. Does that sound right? What happens to the risk of fire when you allow vegetation to grow unchecked?
Aerial view of Virginia City posted to this FB page. Starts with some mining ruins, including hoisting works and tailings.
The view beginning at -1:37 is to the east, away from town, followed by a view to the west, towards town, with a snow-covered Mt. Davidson in the background (originally Sun Mountain).
St. Mary’s church appears at -1:11, followed by the Fourth Ward School at -1:06.
Next is the Silver Terrace Cemetery (NE part of town) at -0:57. The Silverland Inn is at the center of the frame at -0:32.
The view at -0:12 is to the north, showing some of the ‘alphabet’ streets. The main drag running through town is C Street. Mine owners and superintendents lived up the hill on A and B Streets while the rank-and-file lived in the lower part of town, D Street, E street, etc.
The Virginia Range mustangs occasionally pass through the area, as noted in this post.
H/T St. Mary’s in the Mountains.
The chart below shows the stocking rate in animals per thousand acres as a function of land area for HMAs in Nevada. Stocking rates are based on the upper values of the AMLs and include both horses and burros. The stocking rate for the Virginia Range (horses only) is based on a census in early 2018.
Three observations from the chart:
The average HMA in Nevada has 193,000 acres.
The HMA with the largest stocking rate is Fort Sage (formerly Fox Hog).
The largest HMAs are the Nevada Wild Horse Range and Triple B. The smallest is Fort Sage.
The average stocking rate for Nevada HMAs is 0.84 animals per thousand acres.
The chart below shows the population target for HMAs in Nevada as a function of HMA size.
Inspection of the chart yields three conclusions:
Regarding that last point, HMAs with a size of 100,000 acres have an average AML of about 150 animals. If AML varied linearly with size, an HMA of 500,000 acres would have a population target of roughly 750 animals, which is not the case. Larger HMAs have a disproportionally low population target.
The Virginia Range, in the western part of the state, has been included for comparison (actual population, not a target, mostly private land). It does appear to be an outlier compared to the HMAs, with a disproportionally high number of animals for it’s size.
And no, the VR horses are not standing around on dry lots starving to death, as you can see in this video from 2016.
Lone VR bay passing through the high country on 04-20-18.
You just drove two and a half hours to your favorite HMA. Or maybe you went for a hike on the Virginia Range. Just to your west, barely visible, you spot a band of wild horses.
As you’re watching, some of the horses drift closer, including a mare and foal. A yearling steps in first for a closer look. What should you do?
If you’re in a remote area, where the horses have little or no contact with people, this probably won’t happen. You’ll need a long lens. They’ll make sure you keep a safe distance.
What if you’re in a area where the horses are familiar with people? (Recall this example involving burros.)
Some folks say get out of there if approached by a wild horse. Good advice? Or bad lesson for the horse?
Look at the photo above. No high head, no ear pinning, no tail swishing. If you step back, if you move your feet, he wins. You just told the horse you’re lower.
If a horse approaches you respectfully, as in the case above, don’t yield to his pressure. Stand your ground. Push back if you have to. He’ll probably take a few sniffs and move on.
Backing away tells him he’s higher, which may encourage more boldness, more interactions with people. Bad lesson for the horse.
If a horse approaches you aggressively, pick up a rock, a stick, whatever you can get your hands on, and be ready to throw it. Raise your posture, look bigger. Use your voice. He’ll probably steer clear of you. Horses are comfort-seeking animals and don’t like confrontation.
More evidence of overpopulation on the Virginia Range, an area with a stocking rate ten times higher than your average HMA in Nevada, 9.4 horses per thousand acres vs. 0.84 horses (plus a few burros) per thousand acres on HMAs. Photo taken 04/15/18.
Critics argue that the range can’t support these numbers.
Don’t be fooled, they’re not trying to protect the land, they’re trying to protect a narrative.
Public lands inhabited by wild horses and burros in 1971, when the WHB Act was signed into law, are devoted primarily to WHB, right?
Nope, not according to the BLM. Only three areas in the western U.S. are managed principally for horses and one for burros.
Listen carefully to the remarks from 0:05:30 to 0:06:12 in the presentation by John Ruhs, State Director for BLM in Nevada, at this post. The areas of interest, unnamed in the video, are (1) Pryor Mountains Wild Horse Range, (2) Nevada Wild Horse Range, (3) Little Bookcliffs Wild Horse Area and (4) Marietta Wild Burro Range.
Note that all four are listed as HMAs. Little Bookcliffs is referred to as an Area, while the other three are called Ranges.
You have HMAs, you have Ranges, you have Areas. HMAs can be upgraded to Ranges if the Director of the BLM so designates. Only in such cases do the benefits of ‘principally but not exclusively’ apply.
Is that what Congress intended in 1971?
Stocking rates for these areas (based on upper values of AMLs):
The Nevada WH Range is part of Nellis Air Force Base. Principal use is weapons development and flight training, no public access.
H/T Wild Horse Education.
Yep, you can find them here:
Managed for Burros Only
Managed for Horses and Burros
The stocking rate on some of these HMAs is so low that the probability of actually seeing a horse or burro is small. Best chance might be on the Blue Wing Mountains and Warm Springs Canyon HMAs, with stocking rates of 3.6 and 2.2 animals per thousand acres respectively (based on the upper range of the AMLs).
In the burros-only category, Marietta Wild Burro Range is best, with a stocking rate of 1.6 animals per thousand acres.
In addition to the Marietta burros, this video gives you a nice view of the Nevada high desert.
No proposals were received by the NDA for transferring ownership of the Virginia Range horses to a private non-profit advocacy group.
This episode of Bonanza tells the story of Julia Bulette, one of the more ‘colorful’ characters of Virginia City in the mid 1860s. Originally aired 1959.
Roughly half of the wild horses and burros in the U.S. can be found in Nevada. Here are some statistics for the state, developed from individual pages at the BLM web site.
The last figure is offered as an estimate of the current situation, as many of the HMAs have more animals than allowed by the upper value of their AMLs.
The Virginia Range, on the west side of the state and not a part of the BLM system, has a stocking rate of 106 acres per animal (9.4 animals per thousand acres, horses only, mostly private land).
Much of the state falls within the Great Basin, with elevations ranging from 4000 feet in the valleys to over 10,000 feet at some mountain peaks. Annual rainfall varies from four to six inches at lower elevations to 12 to 16 inches in the mountains, making it the driest state in the nation. Areas receiving less than 11 inches per year are considered desert.
It’s a harsh environment, but the horses and burros have adapted to it nicely.
On the trail at Little Bookcliffs Wild Horse Range. It’s not an HMA. Or is it?
Like other areas, horses are subject to humane management practices.
