You can’t make this stuff up! Segment begins at 13:38.
Category: Commentary
Opinion
Swasey Progress Report Day 2
The daily reports indicate 253 wild horses captured as of July 16, with none returned to their home range and no deaths.
Body condition scores ranged from three to five(!) with a few twos.
Not exactly what you’d expect for an area that’s grossly overpopulated.
The fives tell the story: The horses are robbing too much forage from the poor ranchers.
The management plan for the HMA assigns six times more forage to privately owned livestock than horses.
Currituck Horses at Great Risk?
Only 100 remain on the barrier island and “every single one lost is devastating to the genetic health and diversity,” said the herd manager in a report following last week’s choking incident.
She continued, “It’s hard enough to lose one to natural causes … but to lose one to something caused by humans and so easily avoided is just … I don’t even have a word for how bad that is.”
The greatest threat to these animals is not the tourists but the so-called advocates who stalk them with clipboards and darting rifles.
It’s bad when one dies but it’s okay if they’re never born.
You only need to look at Assateague Island (Maryland side) to see where this is going.
The PZP zealots have run that herd into the ground and they know it.
Court Decides Two Wild Horse Cases in Favor of BLM
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals sided with the BLM in its analysis of the effects of releasing a limited number of geldings onto public lands as part of its wild horse management efforts, according to a news release issued today.
In another case, the Court reaffirmed the use of wild horse and burro management plans that cover ten-year periods.
The terms ‘livestock’ and ‘multiple use’ appear nowhere in the announcement, as if the horses and burros have full use of the resources in their home range and are now far beyond its ability to support them.
The problem is most of the resources have been diverted to privately owned livestock.
Roundups may be necessary when the capacity limit of an area is reached, as seen earlier today in the Sheepshead HMA, but they can’t be justified when the forage assigned to livestock could support all of the ‘excess’ horses in an area, and more, as seen last week at the Coyote Lake HMA.
A Lesson from Industrial Quality Control
One day the QC manager at a manufacturing plant said “Starting tomorrow we shall have no more defects.”
Nonsense!
You can’t achieve a desired result by exhorting the workers.
You have to study the system that produces the defects and fix those causes. Off-spec materials, worn out machinery, inadequate training, outdated procedures, etc.
Workers can do nothing about those things.
Defects are downstream, the system is upstream. The behavior of a system as a function of time is called a ‘process.’ A process takes certain inputs and delivers certain outputs, days, weeks or months later.

A major-league hitter gets paid millions of dollars to turn out 70% defective work.
A stable process can turn out 100% defective results, day in and day out.
To solve problems, you have to look upstream and improve the process.
Another Documentary on Wild Horses in the Works?
Free-roaming horses on western rangelands. Then the helicopters come. Many people already know this.
What will be the point of the new film? To break new ground by looking upstream in the wild horse management process? Or will it be a rehash of the same old propaganda about overpopulation, no natural predators, etc?
Will it treat symptoms or identify causes?
Will it promote contraceptives, sanctuaries, adoption and training? Who’s behind it?
Links in the video description point to socialist media except this one. Comments are not allowed.
RELATED: Stop the [Causes of] Roundups!
Why Do Some Wild Horse Advocates Bash Oil Companies?
From page 97 in the Final EA for wild horse management actions at the Barren Valley Complex in southeast Oregon:
Q. Can the EA disclose water usage of each oil and gas rig, wind turbine and geothermal plant; the number of acres designated for buildings/equipment associated with them; and their effects on sage-grouse, wildlife and wild horses?
A. This issue is outside the scope of the analysis as there are no oil/gas rigs, wind turbines or geothermal plants within the vicinity of the HMA.
The EA actually considers three HMAs so perhaps the answer should say “within the vicinity of the Complex?”
Wind turbines make electricity from (OMG) wind. Hydroelectric plants make electricity from falling water, which is clean, dependable and affordable but gets no traction in the media. Wind turbines are better because they don’t chop up fish.
Geothermal plants might need water for cooling tower makeup, if they use water-cooled condensers. Some of these plants use fin-fan condensers, which reject heat to the air.
These plants are often closed loop—whatever comes out of the ground as steam goes back in as condensate, but some water may be needed to make up for system losses.
Maybe we’ll take these people more seriously when they can provide an estimate of the number of wild horses that can be returned to the range if drilling was stopped.
The amount of land needed to set up drilling rigs is miniscule compared to the amount of land (and forage) devoured by public-lands ranching.

Montana Grazing Fees
A draft environmental assessment for livestock grazing on the Pumpkin Creek allotment shows average grazing fees of $12.92 per AUM on state-owned lands and $26.50 per AUM on private lands. See page 26 in the EA (page 30 in the pdf).
The fee on BLM lands is $1.35 per AUM, about 5% of the going rate on private lands.
The government pays about $60 per AUM for wild horses in long-term holding.
The allotment is about 15 miles south of Miles City in the eastern part of the state, according to a news release issued yesterday.
Review of New WH Population Control Plan Almost Complete?
The plan was issued on May 8. Congress had sixty days to review it. That period ends tomorrow. Legislators authorized $21 million in FY 2020 to implement the first part of the rancher-friendly ‘Path Forward’ but only after the BLM “submits a comprehensive and detailed plan for an aggressive, non-lethal population control strategy.”
RELATED: Strategy for Implementing ‘Path Forward’ Sent to Congress.
Stop the [Causes of] Roundups!
If you read environmental assessments for management actions on HMAs, you may have seen statements like this:
The elimination of livestock grazing in an area would require an amendment to the RMP. Changes to grazing cannot be made through a wild horse gather decision.
Roundups, fertility control, sex ratio skewing and sterilization are products of a decision making process that determines the use of public lands.
Those decisions are influenced by other standards, such as the No Rancher Left Behind Act of 1976, as well as the beliefs and loyalties of those involved.
Adoptions, training programs and sanctuaries are too far downstream in the process to be of any use to the horses and burros still on the range.
They are symptoms, not causes.
How far upstream in the process would you have to go to bring about the desired change? How often do Resource Management Plans come up for review? What type of safeguards are protecting them?
RELATED: Stop the Roundups, Fertility Control is Better!

Shocker: TCF Pushes PZP in Latest Opinion Piece
Refer to this column in the Washington Examiner, just published. You just found out that four of the five bedrooms in your home are reserved for other mandated users.
Solution? Contraceptives.
Don’t you dare try to evict the squatters.
Pendley to Head BLM?
The President announced today his intent to nominate William Perry Pendley to be the director of the BLM, subject to confirmation, according to a BLM news release. He has been serving as acting director of the agency since July 2019.
More information in this report by The Hill.
Public Meeting This Week for Aerial Roundups in Nevada
BLM said yesterday that the annual hearing for the use of aircraft and motor vehicles in managing wild horses and burros would be held in Battle Mountain June 25.
What if those attending said “We object.” What would that accomplish?
Roundups are effects, not causes. They are symptoms of the way public lands are managed. If you want change, you have to go after the causes.
The announcement said the state’s wild horse and burro population currently exceeds 51,500 animals, with 12,811 animals allowed by plan. Is that a problem?
The meeting should not be about what type of equipment is most effective in removing these animals from their home range, but why they are being removed from their home range and what can be done to stop it.

Devil’s Garden Horses Rehomed to Northern Colorado
The behavior praised in this video is the same one condemned on their home range.
Fuels reduction is a good idea, unless it’s on grazing allotments.
RELATED: Devil’s Garden Horses Get Short End of Stick.
Who Invented the Wild Horse Darting Machine?
Almost certainly it was somebody with ties to oil or mining companies.
Let’s take a look at the developer’s bios.
Oh crap, it was invented by a rancher.
Major Threat to Wild Horses?
Public-lands ranchers don’t hide their disdain for wild horses. The Public Lands Council, a cheerleader group attached to the National Cattlemen’s Beef Association, makes their position known on this page.
The American Petroleum Institute, a trade group for the energy industry, must have a similar page on its site. After all, oil and gas companies are major threats to wild horses according to some advocacy groups.
See if you can find it.
After that, please indicate
- How much forage has been lost to oil and gas exploration and production
- How many horses have been displaced from public lands by those operations
- How much AMLs can be increased by ending oil and gas production on those lands
What’s that? Still haven’t found that policy statement on the API web site?
RELATED: Where Are Your Figures?
Crowd Panics Currituck Foal
A colt separated from his mom was surrounded by onlookers on Friday, causing him to panic, according to a report posted today by The News & Observer of Raleigh, NC.
Remember, you should never approach wild horses—unless you’re stalking them with darting rifles, which the local ‘advocacy’ group does on a routine basis.
New Darting System: How Would It Really Work?
Operation of the machine can’t be all that bad, as the video shows a horse coming back to eat after ‘treatment.’ Most of them probably did the same thing, so it was hard to choose the right clip for the video.

Do you think the user of this equipment will want darted mares eating more of the bait, when there is so much need out in the pasture? Do you think said user will be willing to feed the studs when they come in for a bite?
Hell no!
There must be another feature in the machine that drives the animals out after they’ve been treated or deemed unnecessary, such as an electric shock.
POW! Hit ’em with a dart. Then ZAP! So long sucka!
They Forgot to Mention Privately Owned Livestock
The following video, posted in 2017, shows a prototype of a machine that automatically darts wild horses in the field. The company now seeks investors to commercialize the technology.
The device targets the forequarters of the animals, contrary to the conventional wisdom in the darting world. It is not clear how the PZP zealots, whose purpose in life is now at risk, will respond.
Oil and mining companies, the greatest threat to wild horses and burros according to some ‘advocacy’ groups, have shown little interest in the contraption.
RELATED: New Machine Darts Wild Horses Automatically.
Wild Horse Population Control Plan Still in the News
You can’t have a conversation about wild horses without having a conversation about public-lands ranching, but a story published yesterday by KSL News of Salt Lake City does exactly that.
Why don’t the horses have any natural predators? Public-lands ranching.
Why can’t the land support more than 27,000 wild horses? Public-lands ranching.
Why do they leave their HMAs in search of food and water? Public-lands ranching.
Nature determines resource availability but resource allocations—and the problems arising therefrom—are man made.
When you carve out 80% or more of the forage for privately owned livestock, wild horse numbers must go down. The programs are not independent, but intertwined.
The PZP zealots want to see the horses wild and free on their home range, they just don’t want them conceived and born on their home range. Makes perfect sense.
RELATED: Lies of Omission in New WHB Management Strategy.

