Assateague Island Cited as PZP Success Story

Refer to the comments from 40:52 to 42:44 in this radio segment on the ‘Path Forward’ by KNPR of Las Vegas.  The program host asks if there is a perfect model for managing wild horse populations.

The guest, a member of the Wild Horse and Burro Advisory Board and science advisor for Return to Freedom, pointed to Assateague as the gold standard (Maryland side of the island, ponies on the Virginia side are managed by the annual swim).

Seriously?

The size of the herd declined from 78 in November 2018 to 75 in November 2019, there is clear evidence of a problem with its sex ratio and genetic diversity may be inadequate.

And you’re holding that up as an example of success?

The only non-lethal option for on-range management of wild horses and burros in the American west is to end public-lands ranching and restore the WHB Act to its original form.

RELATED: ‘Path Forward’ Discussed.

Ties Between PZP Zealots and Public-Lands Ranchers Revealed

Listen to the remarks from 42:45 to 43:51 in this radio segment on the ‘Path Forward’ by KNPR of Las Vegas.  Yep, reduce horses to allow more vegetation [for the ranchers].

The ill-conceived management plan, which will remove 70% of America’s wild horses and burros from their home range and slow the growth of the remaining herds, was not created by two opposing groups—it was written by comrades in arms!

Wild horse advocates were barred from the process because they’re on the fringe and might try to undo four years of ‘progress.’

RELATED: PZP Zealots Take Pro-Ranching Message to WHBAB.

Contraceptives Are a Back-Door Channel to Sterilization

A few months ago the PZP zealots said darted mares become ‘self-boosting’ after five years.  Now, they refer to mares ‘reactivating’ after five years.  Listen to the remarks from 18:38 to 20:33 in this radio segment on the ‘Path Forward’ by KNPR of Las Vegas.

Folks, these are code words for sterilization.

The PZP zealots are on the same side of the debate as the public-lands ranchers, differing only in methodology.

Don’t give them a penny.

Where Did All the Horses Go-1

‘Path Forward’ Discussed

This 46-minute radio segment by KNPR of Las Vegas features J.J. Goicochea, Nevada state veterinarian and public-lands rancher, Greg Hendricks, director of field operations for American Wild Horse Campaign, and Celeste Carlisle, WHBAB member and science advisor for Return to Freedom.  Listener comments included.

How can the ranchers fatten their cattle on lands where horses are starving?

RELATED: The ‘Path Forward’ is Wrong, Livestock Grazing in Nevada.

Livestock Notably Absent

The population density on the Virginia Range is about ten wild horses per thousand acres, compared to an average of two or three wild horses per thousand acres on lands managed by the BLM.  The aimed-at population density on those lands is one wild horse per thousand acres (to be achieved by the glorious ‘Path Forward’).

Why not ten on BLM lands?  Because most of the forage has been assigned to privately owned livestock.  That’s what drives the roundups and warehousing of wild horses.

Water Tanks 10-03-19

Alto Stallion Found Dead

The shooting occurred in the Lincoln National Forest so the case was turned over to the Forest Service, according to a report posted today by Ruidoso News.

The wild horses of Alto, NM were returned to their home range a year ago after a judge ruled that the state livestock board had taken them into custody illegally.

The incident follows the Clark Mountain wild burro shootings in California and Heber wild horse shootings in Arizona.  No arrests have been made in those cases.

Assateague Sex Ratio Still Favors Mares

NPS said there were 22 males (29.3%) and 53 females (70.7%) on the Maryland side of the island in November, according to a story posted today by WMDT News of Salisbury.

The observed sex ratio of a wild horse herd will rarely be 50/50, but how far must it deviate from that value to indicate problems?

The answer must be found by calculation, using basic statistical formulas, where p-bar = .5 and n = 75.  The range of variation between males and females attributable to natural causes is therefore .327 (32.7%) to .673 (67.3%).

Assateague Census Nov 2019-1

The observed proportions fall outside those limits, so an explanation should be sought.

If the observed proportions fell inside the limits, there would be no clear indication of trouble and an investigation would be a waste of time.  The herd would be treated as if its sex ratio was 50/50, even though the observed value was, say, 38/62.

RELATED: Latest Assateague Census Shows No Improvement.

WHBAB Rubber-Stamps ‘Path Forward?’

At the end of the public comments in last week’s meeting of the WHBAB, the Chair admonished the Board about discussing the ill-conceived management plan for wild horses and burros:

“I want to make this perfectly clear that the BLM Wild Horse and Burro Advisory Board is not part of, has not and do not plan to discuss the Path Forward plan that had been mentioned so many times here.  It was not presented to the board.  It was not presented to BLM.  It was presented to Congress.  And it’s up to Congress to act on it, not this board.  And we will not talk about it.”

Yet the Board’s recommendations to the BLM are nearly identical to those in the plan, according to a story by United Press International.  The number of wild horses and burros on western rangelands must be drastically reduced, with more roundups, more adoptions and something new: Sterilization.

The population target stated in the report—26,715—does not represent the number of wild horses and burros the land can support—it’s not even close—but rather the forage loss the government and its ranching cronies are willing to tolerate.

Whenever you see references in an article to ‘humane management,’ ‘healthy horses’ and ‘healthy rangelands,’ you know you’re being lied to.

PSA_178-1

New WHBAB Member Says ‘Approach Must Change’

Refer to this story by the Daily Miner of Kingman, AZ.  If that means they’ll stop having conversations about wild horses and burros without having conversations about public-lands ranching, then it’s definitely a step in the right direction.

The newly appointed member, who serves in the area of humane advocacy, said there are 50,000 wild horses in federal care and another 88,000 on ranches, according to the report.

Don’t quit your day job, dear.

RELATED: WHBAB Open Positions Filled.

Seaman Range and White River Herds to Be Downsized

BLM said today that wild horses in and around the Seaman Range and White River Herd Areas—lands no longer designated for them—will be removed, starting next week.

The gathers will be carried out with helicopters and will be open to public observation, according to the news release.

The two former HMAs contain about 475,100 acres in eastern Nevada, south of Ely.

The Golden Gate and Seaman Range HAs were combined in the 1980s and are referred to as the Seaman Range HA in the Final Environmental Assessment for the roundups.

Seaman Range White River HA Map-1

Captured animals will be taken to the off-range corrals in Ridgecrest, CA.

The two HAs have no AMLs and are not managed for wild horses, supposedly because they don’t have sufficient resources.  But the horses are there.

So are thousands of privately owned cattle and sheep.  Refer to Tables 2 and 3 in the EA.

The 31,000 AUMs per year offered to the public-lands ranchers would support 2,583 wild horses, but they are to be swept aside in favor of the crony capitalists.

Gather stats and daily reports will be posted to this page.

GIGO in the Wild Horse World

You can’t look at the numbers and then agree with the premise of this story, namely, that WHB populations are outpacing what the range can support—not when there are many more cow/calf pairs on the same land.

The Antelope Complex and Silver King HMA are just two examples (listed in the sidebar on the right under Short End of Stick).

What about policies and programs derived from a faulty premise?

Garbage in, garbage out.