Western Horse Watchers Association
Exposing the Hypocrisy, Lies and Incompetence of the Wild Horse Advocates
An Arizona congressman believes that “some people are frustrated with the wild horses because they use the water tanks or use resources that other animals in the area also need,” according to a report posted this evening by AZFamily of Phoenix.
Who do you suppose that might that be? Is he suggesting a culprit or motive?
RELATED: Residents Want Answers About Heber Wild Horse Shootings, Gossip About Motives in Heber Wild Horse Shootings?
The project will streamline the grazing permit process and provide greater flexibility for land and resource management, according to a news release posted today.
Public comments can be submitted until February 28. Project documentation can be found at this page.
As always, comments should be substantive. For example, “The United States does not receive fair market value for forage consumed by domestic livestock on public lands, as required by FLPMA; the fee should be brought in line with market conditions.”
It’s one of the few things that hasn’t been touched by inflation. If gasoline was priced like the grazing fee, you’d be paying about seventeen cents per gallon.
Be sure to compare the allotment map to the HMA map. In which state is public-lands ranching the most prevalent? Where is the largest grazing allotment?
The grazing program fact sheet says that the BLM collected $17.3 million for livestock grazing in 2018. The fee that year was $1.41 per AUM, so 12.3 million AUMs were sold to the public-lands ranchers.
That’s two million cow/calf pairs on 155 million acres, assuming a six month grazing season, for a stocking rate of 12.9 cow/calf pairs per thousand acres.
The stocking rate for wild horses on BLM land is currently about three animals per thousand acres.
Now, which species is overpopulated?
Wild horses on public lands consume about one million AUMs per year.
The forage sold to public-lands ranchers would support ONE MILLION wild horses.
Approximately 50,000 wild horses are warehoused in off-range corrals and pastures.
Livestock allowed on public lands are worth over TWO BILLION DOLLARS, assuming half of them ship to slaughter.
Advocacy groups that push PZP are so far gone—and so out of touch—that you should not be giving them any of your money.
RELATED: Livestock Grazing in Nevada, Public-Lands Ranching Is Big Business.
Eighty wild horses were captured yesterday according to the daily reports, with no deaths reported.
RELATED: Eagle Roundup Delayed?
Thirty federally protected horses have been found dead of possible gunshot wounds in the last 15 months and the investigation has not turned up any suspects or motives.
Some residents and visitors to the forest are worried that the shooter could pose a threat to the public, according to a report posted today by the White Mountain Independent.
A resolution was introduced yesterday in the Kentucky state senate calling for the creation of an Abandoned Horse Task Force. If approved, the group would discuss the problems caused by abandoned horses, ways to stop individuals from abandoning their horses and ways to remove horses currently running at large, according to a report posted today by the Louisville Courier Journal.
The three surviving horses are still roaming the area near the mine and the reward for information on the shootings has risen to $23,000.
You can’t judge a book by its cover but you can certainly discard an editorial on the basis of its preamble.
Perhaps the best solution is just to slaughter the horses.
Have at it.
The linked article, cited as a ‘cover story,’ also gives cover to the public-lands ranchers.
More on that tomorrow.
Nothing has been posted to the daily reports as of this evening. There must be wailing and gnashing of teeth on those allotments.
RELATED: AWHC Seeks Postponement of Eagle Roundup.
Investigators have confirmed that 12 of the 15 animals died from gunshot wounds but the cause of death for the remaining three was not determined, according to a report posted today by FOX10 News of Phoenix.
The story by ABC15 News has a few more details.
RELATED: WMI Says Dead Horses Part of Heber Herd.
Investigators traced the deaths, and dozens of illnesses, to an insect known as the blister beetle, according to a report posted today by AP News.
The eight horses discovered last Friday were from the Heber WHT, according to a story posted this morning by the White Mountain Independent. They were not domestic.
These free-roaming horses are protected by federal law whether they are on their designated territory or not.
RELATED: Heber Death Toll Grows.
One of the group’s organizers says it will concentrate too many horses with too many people in one area, leading to safety problems, according to a report posted this evening by FOX10 News of Phoenix, AZ.
RELATED: Additional Fencing Coming to Salt River.
KPNX News is reporting that seven more horses have been found dead since the original eight were discovered, bringing the total to 15.
RELATED: More Horses Found Dead Near Heber WHT.
BLM said today that operations concluded on January 12, with 420 wild horses gathered from two Herd Areas. Eleven deaths were reported (2.6%) and no horses were returned their home range. Refer to this news release for details.
The gather stats indicated that the captured horses included 48 foals. Is that what you’d expect to find in a herd that’s growing at a rate of 20% per year?
RELATED: Seaman Roundup Continues.
That’s right, they’re gathering, not being gathered. Warm temperatures have lured the horses out of the woods where they shelter from cold winter winds, and into the path of recreational vehicles, according to a report posted this morning by AP News.
RELATED: Helicopter Finds Winter Hideout of Corolla Wild Horses.
On the Salt River with Ryan Marsh.
The roundup announced last week at Eagle HMA, the largest of the three HMAs in the Eagle Complex, will achieve a thriving ecological balance on the affected lands.
Sounds great, but what does that mean in terms of the numbers?
The HMA (not the Complex) contains 670,000 acres according to Table 1 in the final EA and has an AML of 210, for an aimed-at population density (stocking rate) of 0.3 horses per thousand acres.
Because they graze twelve months per year, the forage requirement for the 210 horses allowed by plan is 2,520 AUMs per year.
The next step is to estimate the forage allocated to livestock inside the HMA, the number of cow/calf pairs allowed on the HMA and the cow/calf density in the HMA, to be compared to the same figures for horses.
The HMA intersects nine grazing allotments. The size of the allotments, their grazing seasons, the portions inside the HMA and the historical forage consumption are given in Table 3.2 of the EA.
The permitted AUMs, not given in the table, were estimated from historical use.
For example, the average use at Wilson Creek is 20,408 AUMs per year, which corresponds to 45% of the permitted AUMs. Therefore, the estimated forage consumption allowed by plan on that allotment is 20,408 ÷ .45 = 45,351 AUMs per year.
Likewise for the other allotments. Those figures are shown in red on the following spreadsheet.
The Wilson Creek permittee(s) would have to place 3,779 cow/calf pairs on the allotment to graze off 45,351 AUMs in 12 months (45,351 ÷ 12), for a stocking rate of 3.5 cow/calf pairs per thousand acres (3,779 ÷ 1,090,414 × 1,000).
Given that 47% of the allotment lies within the HMA, the estimated forage available to livestock inside the HMA is 45,351 × .47 = 21,315 AUMs per year, which would feed 1,776 cow/calf pairs over a 12 month grazing season (21,315 ÷ 12).
The total calculated acreage inside the HMA is very close to the 670,000 acres contained by the HMA, so little if any of the HMA is not subject to permitted livestock grazing.
The total estimated forage available to livestock inside the HMA is 25,739 AUMs per year, which would support 2,286 cow/calf pairs over a weighted average grazing season of 11.3 months.
The EA notes on page 24 that “wild horses are present year-round and their impacts to rangeland resources cannot be controlled through establishment of a grazing system, such as for livestock.” Apparently, the writers didn’t notice that the cattle are on the land for roughly the same amount of time!
The estimated stocking rate allowed by plan for livestock inside the HMA is 3.4 cow/calf pairs per thousand acres.
These figures are compared in the following charts.
The thriving ecological balance is not a balance at all. Perhaps the BLM should refer to it as the thriving ecological bias (in favor of privately owned cattle and sheep).
The cattle allowed on the HMA each year are probably worth over $2 million, assuming that half of them ship to slaughter, versus a forage cost of $35,000 at current prices.
The forage allocated to livestock on the HMA would support an additional 2,145 wild horses (25,739 ÷ 12), for an AML of 2,355.
Even in the face of these results, the PZP zealots will spend the weekend cleaning their darting rifles, because they do not want to know the truth about America’s wild horses.
RELATED: Hypothesis, Reiterated, Public-Lands Ranching Is Big Business.
The remains of eight horses were found yesterday in the Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest, near the town of Heber-Overgaard, according to a report posted this evening by KPNX News of Phoenix, AZ.
The deaths were caused by gunshots.
RELATED: Heber Shooting Update.
The organization said yesterday that the BLM violated the public’s First Amendment rights by not announcing the roundup until Thursday and not allowing the public to observe the operation until the second day.
A letter was sent to the BLM asking for a delay, according to a story by AP News.
Workers will start the second phase of the project on Monday. The fence will prevent wild horses from crossing the Bush Highway and will keep livestock from mingling with the horses, according to a report posted today by AP News.
The first phase, which began in November, ended yesterday.
BLM reported that 162 studs, 187 mares and 48 foals had been gathered, as of 01-09-20, with no animals returned to their home range.
The contractor captured more mares than studs but does that result point to anything unusual or can the difference be attributed to chance?
The sex of the foals was not given so their number should be omitted from the total.
The expected proportion of mares and studs is .50 (50%), but that is a property of an indefinitely large number of horses.
The observed proportions are .464 for studs and .536 for mares, with n = 349.
The range of variation attributable to chance can be computed from basic statistical formulas, where p-bar = .50 and n = 349. The observed proportions fall within the calculated limits of .420 and .580, so these results don’t point to anything unusual.
That doesn’t mean the contractor wasn’t asked to alter the herd in some manner, such as skewing the sex ratio of the herd in favor of studs, only that there’s no evidence of that in these data.
Bachelor bands may blend with family bands in a helicopter roundup, resulting in a more-or-less even distribution of males and females in the traps.
Any sex ratio skewing would have to be accomplished by selective return.
RELATED: Seaman Roundup Continues.
Western Horse Watchers Association 