Comments Invited on Confusion Wild Horse Gather EA

Yesterday the BLM announced the opening of a 30-day public comment period on a draft environmental assessment for management actions on the Confusion HMA in western Utah.  The EA looks at the consequences of a proposed action along with those of one or more alternatives.

The HMA covers 235,005 acres in Juab and Millard counties, according to the EA, but the HMA page linked above says 293,665 acres.  The area computed from the data in Table 3a of the EA is 270,574 acres.  (WHW has asked the BLM which figure is correct.)

Confusion HMA Map-1

The maximum number of horses allowed by plan is 115, for an aimed-at stocking rate of 0.5 wild horses per thousand acres, based on the area in the EA.  Recall the observation from April that stocking rates below one may indicate large amounts of forage diverted to privately owned livestock.

The management plan allocates an estimated 10,259 AUMs per year to livestock inside the HMA (88%), according to data in Table 3a, and 1,380 AUMs per year to wild horses (12%).  The AUM distribution will change if the acreage numbers change.

Comments can be submitted online at the project documents page or by US Mail.

Range Creek Roundup Starts Next Week

BLM said today that that approximately 125 wild horses will be gathered from the Range Creek HMA in Carbon County, UT, starting July 1.  The operation will be carried out with helicopters and will be open to public observation.

The HMA covers 55,023 acres and has an AML of 125, for an aimed-at stocking rate of 2.3 wild horses per thousand acres.

Range Creek HMA Map-1

The HMA intersects one grazing allotment, with 3,267 AUMs per year authorized across eight pastures.  The amount of land falling within the HMA was not given in the EA.

Captured animals will be taken to the off-range corrals in Axtell.

Gather stats and daily reports will be posted to this page.

A roundup occurred on the HMA last September, with 154 wild horses removed.

The current population is thought to be 184, plus this year’s foal crop, according to the news release.

Nye County Commissioners Reject Helicopter Roundups

On June 16, County Commissioners approved a resolution opposing helicopter gathers of wild horses and burros within the borders of Nye County, NV, according to a story posted this morning by the Pahrump Valley Times.

The motion passed with all in favor.

The Stone Cabin, Reveille, Hot Creek, Saulsbury and Bullfrog HMAs can be found in Nye County, along with the Nevada WHR.

RELATED: Public Meeting This Week for Aerial Roundups in Nevada.

PLC Wants to Change Image of Public-Lands Ranching

The executive director of the Public Lands Council said earlier this week that public-lands ranching should be viewed as “a land-management tool to reduce fine fuels that lead to intense wildfires, as well as a tool to cultivate native grasses and reduce invasive species,” according to a report by Capital Press of Salem, OR.

She also claimed that “herd management areas are overstocked” and stakeholders in the west are very interested in additional funding for the WHB program.

Residents to Protest Currituck Wild Horse Tours

No looting and burning expected, just some yard signs over the July 4th weekend, according to a story published this morning by The Virginian-Pilot of Norfolk, VA.

Wild horse tourism is a large part of Corolla’s economy.  “People come specifically to see the horses.  Visitors stay in rental houses and eat and shop locally.”

The horses roam on marshes and beaches north of town, near the Virginia border.

The barrier that keeps the horses away from town was damaged last September by Hurricane Dorian.

Comments Invited on Moriah Gather EA

BLM announced yesterday the beginning of a 30-day comment period on a draft environmental assessment for the removal of wild horses in and around the Moriah Herd Area in eastern Nevada.

The HA covers 55,300 acres on the Utah border and has no AML.  Horses were found there in 1971 but the land is no longer managed for them.

Moriah HA Map-1

The HA intersects five grazing allotments according to Section 3.2.9.1 of the EA, with cattle and sheep present most of the year.

Note 13 on page seven of the BLM map says “Unsuitable habitat – (unproductive land – inadequate forage),” yet the area can provide an estimated 4,034 AUMs per year to privately owned livestock, based on data in Table 4, enough to support 336 horses.

The current population in and around the HA is thought to be 714, including this year’s foal crop.  The animals routinely move outside the HA in search of food and water.

All of the horses have been designated ‘excess’ and therefore subject to removal.

The Moriah HMA lost its HMA status in the 2008 Ely District Record of Decision and Approved Resource Management Plan.

The roundup, when it occurs, will likely capture only 75% to 85% of the horses and follow-up actions may be necessary over the next ten years to achieve management objectives, according to section 2.2 of the EA.

Comments must be submitted by email or sent by US Mail to the Ely District Office.

An online form was not provided with the project documents.

Public Meeting This Week for Aerial Roundups in Nevada

BLM said yesterday that the annual hearing for the use of aircraft and motor vehicles in managing wild horses and burros would be held in Battle Mountain June 25.

What if those attending said “We object.”  What would that accomplish?

Roundups are effects, not causes.  They are symptoms of the way public lands are managed.  If you want change, you have to go after the causes.

The announcement said the state’s wild horse and burro population currently exceeds 51,500 animals, with 12,811 animals allowed by plan.  Is that a problem?

The meeting should not be about what type of equipment is most effective in removing these animals from their home range, but why they are being removed from their home range and what can be done to stop it.

Thriving Ecological Balance-3

Major Threat to Wild Horses?

Public-lands ranchers don’t hide their disdain for wild horses.  The Public Lands Council, a cheerleader group attached to the National Cattlemen’s Beef Association, makes their position known on this page.

The American Petroleum Institute, a trade group for the energy industry, must have a similar page on its site.  After all, oil and gas companies are major threats to wild horses according to some advocacy groups.

See if you can find it.

After that, please indicate

  • How much forage has been lost to oil and gas exploration and production
  • How many horses have been displaced from public lands by those operations
  • How much AMLs can be increased by ending oil and gas production on those lands

What’s that?  Still haven’t found that policy statement on the API web site?

RELATED: Where Are Your Figures?

Rule of Four Accounts for Horses in Long-Term Holding

How many wild horses in long-term holding can be explained by the ‘rule of four?’

All of them.  A quick estimate of the number of horses cheated out of spot on their home range by privately owned livestock is

27,000 × 4 = 108,000

If you removed domestic livestock from half of the HMAs, you could empty all of the off-range corrals and pastures.

But why stop there?  Cattle and sheep belong on private land, not wild horses.