Chincoteague Pony Auction Falls Short of Last Year

Thunderbolt was the top producer going into today’s event, credited with ten foals, but Ace was the top earner, generating $70,600 for the fire company.  A disputed foal may also be his, which would add another $50,000.

Colts outnumbered fillies 46 to 42 in this year’s foal crop, but fillies attracted $361,100 in bids compared to $274,500 for colts.

The total paid was $635,600, compared to over $1 million in 2025.

Of the 88 foals born in the refuge, 80 were offered for sale.

The seven buybacks averaged $33,886 per head, compared to $5,458 per head for the others.

The highest bid went to Tuney, one of the buybacks, for $60,000.

Six of the buybacks were female, setting the stage for more production and greater income in 2027.

Auction results provided by Superior Livestock Auction.

Refer to this spreadsheet for a ranking of sires.

List of foals by DSC Photography.

Comments on 2025 auction.

PREVIOUS: Chincoteague Pony Auction in Progress.

► Get the truth about wild horses and the wild horse advocates at westernhorsewatchers.com.

Leave a comment