Another Sign the Advocates Want the Ranchers to Win

You’re seeing cow poop where you previously saw horse poop.

The Campaign Against America’s Wild Horses, a leader in nonmotorized removal and staunch opponent of principal use, pursues the Virginia Range mares relentlessly.

The PZP darting program, now in its sixth year, has moved into the sterilization phase, which may explain why it hasn’t posted the Year 6 agreement with NDA to its darting resources page.

It may contain terms like “tipping point” and “no looking back,” as its adherents lucture you about the safety and reversibility of the pesticide.

This bogus advocacy group will do anything to win the approval of the bureaucrats and ranchers, including total herd destruction.

RELATED: If You Want to Help the Ranchers Give Money to the Advocates.

Cowpie on Virginia Range 09-25-24

Best Use of Twin Peaks AUMs?

The HMA sits on top of nine grazing allotments, discussed in Section 3.2.2 of the Final EA for pest control and resource enforcement therein.

The map in Appendix H shows the arrangement (page 103 in the pdf).

The National Data Viewer indicates that some of the allotments extend beyond the HMA boundary, taking with them a small percentage of the active AUMs, but that will be ignored in this report.

The management plan allows 758 wild horses in the HMA plus 116 wild burros.

These animals require 758 × 12 + 116 × 6 = 9,792 AUMs per year.

The Allotment Master Report provides management status, acreage and active AUMs.

Twin Peaks Allotment Calcs 09-24-24

The allotments offer 26,803 active AUMs per year on 656,475 public acres.

Approximately 99% of that acreage is in the Improve category.

The AUMs would support 2,234 wild horses, on top of the 758 allowed by plan.

The pre-gather population of 1,800 is well within this range.

Current management practices give the resource to the ranchers, who pay $1.35 per AUM, while consigning 2,234 wild horses to off-range holding at a cost of $5 per head per day.

The cash flow in this scenario, Alternative A, is:

1.35 × 26,803 – 2,234 × 5 × 365 = -$4,040,865.95 per year

The Proposed Action, Alternative B, would shift the resource back to the horses by confining the ranchers to their base properties, for a cash flow of zero.

No income from grazing, no expenditure for off-range holding, with net savings to taxpayers of $4 million per year.

RELATED: Twin Peaks Roundup Announced.

Thriving Ecological Balance-3

If Wild Horses Had Principal Use of East Walker, Lucky Boy and Nine Mile

The permits on these allotments, located west of Hawthorne, NV, are up for renewal.

They offer a combined 5,102 active AUMs on 71,998 public acres, according to the Allotment Master Report.

The forage assigned to horses is zero.

How many wild horses could live there?

Using the principle of forage interchangeability, the True AML would be 5,102 ÷ 12 = 425, the number of horses the land could support if it was managed principally for them as specified in the original statute.

The stocking rate would be 425 ÷ 71,998 × 1,000 = 5.9 wild horses per thousand public acres.

Why is this important?

The bureaucrats and ranchers tell us that public lands in the western U.S. can only support one wild horse per thousand acres (27,000 animals on 27 million acres).

The advocates, defeated a long time ago and now one of their allies, give their assent through their darting programs.

If the allotments were an HMA, the AML would be 72 and 353 horses would be consigned to off-range holding because of permitted grazing.

BLM allotments in Nevada carry livestock equivalent to 173,144 wild horses on 40,194,360 public acres, or 4.3 wild horses per thousand public acres.

Wild horses can be placed on public lands not identified for their use by acquiring base properties associated with grazing allotments and flipping the preference to horses, as American Prairie did for bison in Montana.

RELATED: The Allotments Tell the Story: They’re Lying, All of Them.

East Walker Lucky Boy Nine Mile Allotments 09-23-24

Scoping Begins for Wyoming Honor Farm Contract Renewal

One document has been copied to the project folder.

A forthcoming environmental assessment will evaluate the wild horse gentling and adoption partnership between BLM Wyoming and the Wyoming Department of Corrections as well as other alternatives, according to today’s news release.

Comments will be accepted through October 23.

RELATED: What’s Happening at Wyoming Honor Farm?

SHOCKER: New PLC President Is a Public-Lands Rancher

He assumed the role at the end of the 56th Annual Meeting according to a September 20 news release.

As a role model for the industry, his allotments meet or exceed standards for rangeland health.  Right?

The Operator Information and Allotment Information reports at RAS tied him to these authorizations and allotments, all in the Royal Gorge Field Office.

  • 0502003 – WEST BOX CANYON
  • 0503694 – HAYDEN RANCH
  • 0503746 – BEAR CREEK
  • 0505292 – HOWARD CREEK
  • 0505310 – MAVERICK GULCH

The Allotment Master Report provides management status, acreage and active AUMs.

Canterbury Allotment Calcs 09-23-24

The operation is on the small side, putting the new president in the figurehead category.

All of the public acres are in the Improve category, which should be an embarrassment to PLC.

The parcels support livestock equivalent to 70 wild horses, with an average stocking rate of 4.8 animals per thousand public acres.

The bureaucrats and ranchers tell us that public lands in the western U.S. can only support one wild horse per thousand acres (27,000 animals on 27 million acres), which should bring more embarrassment.

The advocates, defeated a long time ago and now in their camp, bolster the narrative with their darting programs.

RELATED: Winners of 2024 Stewardship Awards Announced.

Relationship Between Active AUMs and Permitted Use

The Allotment Master Report provides both.

In this example from the Blue Wing Allotment in Nevada, C-Punch Ranch receives 14,058 active AUMs but the permitted use is 25,864.

Blue Wing AUMs 09-22-24

Which one represents the forage allocation for livestock?

Sometimes the BLM moves AUMs into the suspended column because of fires, drought, solar arrays, mines, etc.

Those AUMs can shift back to active use when conditions improve or after the useful life of the project.

The relationship between these variables is:

Active AUMs = Permitted UseSuspended AUMs

or

Permitted Use = Active AUMs + Suspended AUMs

Western Horse Watchers uses active AUMs when comparing forage allocations for wild horses and livestock.

RELATED: What Do the AUM Numbers Tell You About an HMA?

Winners of 2024 Stewardship Awards Announced

The Rangeland Stewardship Award in the permittee category went to Fitzgerald Ranch of Plush, OR according to a BLM news release dated September 17.

The Operator Information Report at RAS tied the ranch to authorizations 3600601 and 3601273.

The Allotment Information Report linked the authorizations to these allotments:

  • 3600601 – NORTHEAST WARNER
  • 3601273 – SHALE ROCK, FITZGERALD FFR, COYOTE-COLVIN, ABERT SEEDING, SOUTH RABBIT HILLS

The Allotment Master Report provides management status, public acres and active AUMs.

Fitzgerald Allotment Calcs 09-20-24

Approximately 92% of the public acres are in the Improve category, suggesting that our stewards of the public lands are not taking their responsibilities seriously.

The allotments support livestock equivalent to 1,427 wild horses on 298,288 public acres, or 4.8 wild horses per thousand public acres.

The bureaucrats and ranchers tell us that public lands in the western U.S. can only support one wild horse per thousand public acres (27,000 animals on 27 million acres).

The award was presented at the annual meeting of the Public Lands Council.

RELATED: Winners of 2023 Stewardship Awards Announced.

Advocates Not Ill-Informed on Subject of Wild Horses?

So says one of their leaders in today’s news release on PRN.

Judge for yourself.

They’ve published a list of recommendations for the BLM covering ethical and effective wild horse and burro management.

It was developed at the SOWH Conference in Reno where there was no condemnation of the Virginia Range mass sterilization program, despite its proximity to the hotel-casino.

The page includes a form that will add your name to the signatories.

Western Horse Watchers offers the following suggestions as a starting point for meaningful discussion.

  • Confine the ranchers to their base properties in a year-round off season
  • Restore the WHB Act to its original form
  • Neutralize the influence of farm bureaus, stock grower’s associations, public lands councils and wildlife groups on government
  • Acquire base properties as they come on the market and flip the grazing preference to horses or burros
  • Keep the pesticide pushers off the public lands

A guiding principle in the SOWH recommendations is that they could be implemented without any changes to policy and law.

The cover letter was not addressed to anyone in the Department of Agriculture, which is responsible for wild horses and burros on Forest Service lands.

RELATED: SOWH Releases Videos from Reno Conference.

End of Line for Kisatchie Horses?

The Army base is now Fort Johnson, not Fort Polk, according to a story by The Advocate of Baton Rouge, LA.

The number of horses remaining in the forest is unknown.

An advocacy group filed suit claiming the Army’s plan to eliminate the horses violates the National Environmental Policy Act and the National Historic Preservation Act but the courts ruled in favor of the military, who views the herd as trespass livestock.

Although the group rescued around 100 animals, they have separated the males from the females, suggesting there are no plans to preserve the resource.

RELATED: Louisiana’s Fort Polk Horses a Unique Genetic Resource?

Foal-Free Friday, Gaslighting Your Supporters Edition

The Campaign Against America’s Wild Horses oversees an innovative fertility control program on the Virginia Range according to an August 31 news flash distributed by Lucky Three Ranch.

It’s designed preserve the wild horse herd.

The advocates shoot the females with pesticide-laced darts.

After five years of treatment they become sterile.

The program is now in its sixth year.

The mares enjoy a well-deserved break from the demands of nursing and pregnancy, allowing them to maintain strong health and a steady weight.

The fillies, also targeted, thrive without the strain of early pregnancy, giving them the time they need to grow strong and healthy.

As the older horses die.

Does it make sense now?

Thank God for the wild horse advocates.

RELATED: Foal-Free Friday, Abandoning Principal Use Edition.

Calling it a Vaccine 05-01-23

Hold Your Horses: Little Book Cliffs Roundup Not Complete

Yesterday’s news release says it’s over although some horses are still being sorted to determine which ones will receive fertility treatments, moved to different areas of the HMA or taken to a holding facility.

The gather page indicates 59 unaccounted-for animals.

Little Book Cliffs Roundup Stats Day 8 09-19-24

A report by The Colorado Sun indicates that a mare, 24 years old and underweight—but with foal—was dispatched on Day 8 after she broke her leg.

The foal went to a local ranch.

The roundup is not over until the disposition of every captured animal is known.

RELATED: Little Book Cliffs Roundup, Day 7.

Wild Horse Adoptions Conserve Public Lands?

Suppose you adopt a mom-baby pair at one of the BLM off-range corrals, captured earlier this year in a wild horse roundup.

How much does the on-range population change?

What is the change in resource loading?

How many public acres were conserved?

Zip, zero and zilch, respectively.

So why would the writer of an opinion piece in today’s edition of The Nevada Independent peddle wild horse adoptions as conservation?

Because they free-up space in the corrals, allowing more horses to be taken off the range, conserving resources for the public-lands ranchers.

The author forgot to mention them.

“The equines generally inhabit rugged, remote, arid landscapes where they compete with mule deer, pronghorn, sage-grouse and other wildlife for water and forage.”

There aren’t many predators in those areas because they have been minimized in the name of animal agriculture.

Public lands in Nevada can’t support 38,000 wild horses and burros but they can support livestock equivalent to 173,000 wild horses.

The Property and Environment Research Center advocates for market solutions to conservation so let’s put labels on range-fed beef saying it was produced on public lands at the expense of America’s wild horses and let consumers pick the winners and losers.

RELATED: AIP Turns 5.

Range Fed Beef